Prevu by reAlpha
BuySellBlogBrowse Listings
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore NY 11706
New York>Suffolk County>Bay Shore

35 S Penataquit AvenueBay Shore, NY 11706

For Sale

$1,999,999

Smart Buyer Rebate $20,000

Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer.
This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four working fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.

Listed by Margaret T. Smith SRS CRB CIREC CB

·

Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty

·

631-647-7013

Last updated September 19, 2025

·

Source: OneKey #847363

Listing Facts

  • TypeSingle-family
  • NeighborhoodBay Shore
  • Bedrooms9
  • Bathrooms5
  • Days on Prevu204
  • Taxes$25,395.99/year
  • Size5,646 sqft
  • Price per sqft$354

Amenities

  • Dishwasher
  • Private Outdoor Space
  • Washer/Dryer

Location

Mortgage Calculator

Listing History

09/19/2025
Price Decreased
$1,999,999
05/21/2025
Listed by Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$2,350,000

Property Details for 35 S Penataquit Avenue

Exterior

Construction

  • Property Attached: Yes
  • Year Built: 1890
  • Architectural Style: Other
  • Construction Materials: Cedar, Frame

Features

  • Patio And Porch Features: Deck, Porch

Measurements

  • Building Area Units: Square Feet
  • Lot Size Acres: 1.40
  • Lot Size Square Feet: 60,984

Financial

Taxes

  • Parcel Number: 0500-394-00-02-00-027-000
  • Tax Annual Amount: $25,395.99
  • Tax Assessed Value: $77,900.00
  • Tax Year: 2024

Interior

Features

  • Appliances: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Oven, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Trash Compactor, Washer, Gas Water Heater, Wine Refrigerator
  • Fireplace: Yes
  • Fireplaces Total: 4
  • Interior Features: Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, High Ceilings, Primary Bathroom, Storage

Measurements

  • Living Area: 5,646
  • Living Area Source: Public Records

Rooms

  • Basement: Full, Partially Finished
  • Has Basement: Yes
  • Bathrooms Full: 4
  • Bathrooms Half: 1
  • Bathrooms Total Integer: 5
  • Bedrooms Total: 9
  • Rooms Total: 18

Other

General

  • Exclusions: DR, Kitchen Chandeliers, Urns, Drapes

Parking

Parking

  • Garage Spaces: 3
  • Garage: Yes

Schools

Elementary School

  • Elementary School: Brook Avenue Elementary School
  • Elementary School District: Bay Shore

High School

  • High School: Bay Shore Senior High School
  • High School District: Bay Shore

Middle or Junior School

  • Middle Or Junior School: Bay Shore Middle School
  • Middle Or Junior School District: Bay Shore

Utilities

Equipment

  • Cooling: Ductless, Wall/Window Unit(s)
  • Heating: Natural Gas
  • Sewer: Public Sewer
  • Utilities: Natural Gas Connected
  • Water Source: Private, Public

Frequently Asked Questions

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does this single-family home have?

There are 9 bedrooms and 5 bathrooms in this single-family home at 35 S Penataquit Avenue.

What schools are nearby to 35 S Penataquit Avenue?

Nearby schools include the Brook Avenue Elementary School, Bay Shore Middle School, and Bay Shore Senior High School.

Does this single-family home have parking?

Yes, there are 3 parking spaces available for 35 S Penataquit Avenue.

What are the annual taxes for 35 S Penataquit Avenue?

Annual taxes for this single-family home are estimated at $25,395.

How does 35 S Penataquit Avenue compare to other single-family homes in Bay Shore?

This single-family home is listed 159% above the average price for single-family homes in Bay Shore and has been on the market for 121 more days than the typical home in this area.

What is the square footage on this single-family home?

According to the MLS, this listing is 5,646 sqft.

35 S Penataquit Avenue is a 9-bedroom, 5-bath single-family home for sale in Bay Shore NY 11706. Listed on Prevu for 204 days at $1,999,999. This includes a recent price decrease of $350,001. This property features 5,646 square feet of living space, located in Bay Shore. The median listing price for single-family homes in this area is $640,000. Nearby schools include Brook Avenue Elementary School, Bay Shore Middle School, and Bay Shore Senior High School. Additional amenities include private outdoor space, dishwasher, and washer/dryer. Browse more single-family home listings in Suffolk County.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the IDX Program of OneKey™ MLS. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. Information Copyright 2025, OneKey™ MLS. All Rights Reserved.

Full MLS Disclaimers

Rebate estimate is indicative only and based on listing price and estimated buyer's agent commission paid by owner, if applicable. Final rebates are subject to Terms of Use and may vary due to final negotiated transaction terms.